LCMC's Original Ministry Board
What do you do when you leave your denomination, do not join another denomination, but instead start your own? That was the question for a bunch of us when we left the ELCA and formed the LCMC. Very early on, we realized that class had not been available in seminary! What do we do now?
Where are we going to train our pastors? How are we going to call our pastors? What about congregations that can’t find an ordained pastor? Those were the burning questions.
I had the honor of serving on the first Ministry Board of the LCMC, which was accountable to the Board of Trustees. The Ministry Board had a kind of eclectic membership, but shared a love for Christ, the Church, and pastors. At times, it was like herding cats; at other times, it was like a powerful movement of the Holy Spirit unifying.
We were tasked with drafting ministry standards, developing call process guidelines, establishing relationships with seminaries to train future pastors, and handling congregational issues related to pastoral conflict. We were around 25-30 congregations at the time, so we wanted to meet not only current needs at the time, but also to look forward to the future.
We presented the LCMC Ministry Standards to the LCMC Annual Gathering & Convention after reviewing them with the Board of Trustees. Part of what was adopted was the following:
“This association affirms the priesthood of all believers. It commits itself in function and structure to equip and support all members of its congregations for their ministries within and outside of the household of faith. It is within and from this context of ministry that we declare that some are called by God to the public ministry of Word and Sacrament and other specific ministries. At the same time, all baptized members of our congregations are priests called by God to ministries in their daily lives. (LCMC Constitution – Article 3 – Ministry 3.01)
These ministry standards and procedures identify qualities of and qualifications for LCMC clergy.
Congregations are responsible to call their pastor. A call from a congregation may be either a certified or a contract call. They are defined below.
Congregations may call an individual to serve in their congregation with a certified call. This means they are calling an individual who is on the LCMC clergy list. Congregations are encouraged to support continuing education for those they call. The congregation will determine the title for the position held by a person with a certified call. Standards and terminology may vary by district or congregation.
Congregations may call an individual to serve in their congregation with a contract call. This means they are calling an individual who is not recognized by the association as a certified candidate. Persons called on a contract basis may provide ministry according to their gifts, and as negotiated with the congregation. Further training is recommended. Some candidates may seek to acquire training which leads to certification, while they serve in a contract call capacity. The congregation will determine the title for the position held by a person with a contract call. Standards and terminology may vary by district or congregation. "
We produced a document titled Call Process Guidelines for congregational call committees realizing different sized congregations needed some flexibility. One of the fundamental tenets of the LCMC is that congregations are free to call who they want. We found this an incredible opportunity for congregations to grow, but some were intimidated because their prior experience with the call process was to be hand-fed. The guidelines were written with this sensitivity.
When it came to training pastors, we met with Dr. Michael Rogness “in the dead of the night” and asked him, “If you could start from scratch, what model would you use to train future pastors?” He said almost without missing a beat, “An apprentice experience embedded in the congregation!” That philosophy became a guide for us. We, of course, acknowledged other training scenarios. We visited numerous seminaries, explaining our expectations for our certified pastors to see if they could and were willing to train them. The working relationship with seminaries has evolved over time with different schools coming and going.
We outlined this process in the adopted Ministry Standards with the following language:
- Candidates will have a Bachelor’s degree or its equivalent and a Master of Divinity degree from an accredited theological school or its equivalent.
- If possible, a mentoring pastor assigned by a ministry committee will develop a relationship with students while that student is in seminary.
- When appropriate, psychological testing may be administered.
- For students or graduates of non-Lutheran seminaries, the ministry committee will decide what additional education should be assigned.
- Candidates will have a year of internship/residency or its equivalent. This can be a regular seminary internship; an internship arranged by a ministry committee, or an equivalent experience, such as previous supervised work in a congregation.
- Clinical Pastoral Education (CPE) may be selectively required.
- Candidates will participate in a certification interview with a ministry committee. Upon completion of the certification interview and approval for a certified call, the LCMC office will be informed of the candidate’s availability for call.
- Clergy on the roster of another denomination, who wish to become listed as LCMC clergy, can apply to the colloquy process in LCMC.
- To have a certified call, a candidate must have a letter of call from a congregation.
- Upon completion of the above, the candidate can be ordained/installed.
The language, “candidates will have a Master of Divinity degree from an accredited theological school or its equivalent” was both masterful and frustrating. It allowed for the freedom to develop new forms of higher education, but did not articulate what “equivalent” meant. It has proved to be a great source of conversation on the one hand and disagreement on the other.
When it came to congregational conflicts, they were rare at that time due to our few numbers and accountability was happening naturally because we knew each other. Unfortunately, they still occurred. We expected that change would be needed to help congregations as the association grew in size and geographically spread in the US and worldwide. That proved to be true. We saw districts as not only helpful in this arena but also necessary. The problem was that not all congregations joined a district.
We tried to set the LCMC on a solid but mailable ministry foundation. Finding the right balance was challenging, but we prayerfully discussed, deliberated, and decided. Shockingly, we all remained friends!
Those great friendships I still cherish to this day. They all continue to be in my thoughts and prayers.
I am sure if I showed up at a Ministry Board meeting today, aspects of it would be very different, and yet a familiarity would probably hang in the air. I pray that it will have matured to be less like herding cats and more like a powerful movement of the Holy Spirit, unifying the board with the tasks and challenges at hand! I pray for them as well.
Share this post
Click Here For Content Archives